Their flagship Oxford shirt has been made from the same fabric since 1978, a slight riff on the traditional material with a slightly lighter 5-ounce cotton woven into a finer basketweave.

The Oxford cotton — milled in Italy — that the shirt is made from has a pleasing weightiness, too, and reminds me of old Ralph Lauren button-downs. (If you prefer a different material ...

Our top pick overall is the Bonobos Everyday Oxford, which is made of 100% cotton with built-in stretch that works for any build. Another great option is the Mizzen+Main Leeward Dress Shirt ...