We’ll be the ones to say it: 90s makeup was peak makeup ... Plus, per Who What Wear, both Selena Quintanilla and Madonna often rocked the shade; so that’s the coolest. Frosted lipsticks ...

Sabrina Carpenter's latest muse is '90s Madonna clad in a gold Jean Paul Gaultier ... into voluminous curls by Guido Palau, while her makeup oozed soft glam with a glittery eye, dark brows ...