Outward Hound's Hide-a-Squirrel Plush Toy is the best of the three stuffed puzzles Sarah Saril, Insider Reviews deals editor, and her German shepherds Davey and Papaya and chihuahua Disco tested.

The toy also has a soft exterior and a plush filling that appeals to dogs ... tossed around and chewed on by my 8-month-old basset hound. However, this isn't suitable if your puppy is a strong ...