Several 'American Idol' hopefuls performed Carrie Underwood's hits when the country star joined the judging panel for season 23

Carrie Underwood was taken aback by an American Idol contestant - not for the first time this series - and found herself singing along to her own anthem, "Waiting All Day For Sunday Night." The 2005 American Idol winner is now a judge on the hit show and was treated to a rendition of her famous song,

ABC's American Idol Season 23 hopeful, JMarie's soulful rendition of Carrie Underwood's Before He Cheats, earns her a spot in Hollywood.