Clutterbuck became a popular teammate and fan favorite, playing his final 794 regular-season and playoff games with the Islanders to reach 1,145 in his career. He helped them make seven postseason appearances,

The winger played 11 seasons with the Islanders including 10 as an alternate captain and reigns as the NHL’s leader in hits

Cal Clutterbuck’s last NHL game came on April 30, 2024, when the Hurricanes eliminated the Islanders in Game 5 of their first-round series. The former fourth-line agitator spent this season as a pre- and post-game analyst for the team’s MSG Networks’ broadcasts.